Insurance company

Insurance Company Ratings Explained | The bank rate

When it comes to buying insurance, many people prioritize the cost of a policy as part of the decision-making process. And while your insurance policy should fit your budget, there’s more to insurance than the price you pay. There are other factors you may also want to consider when selecting an insurance company, such as customer satisfaction ratings, claims reimbursement history, and reputation in the industry. industry scale, which you can learn by looking at insurance company ratings. Considering these third-party ratings can help you determine an insurer’s ability to pay claims on time and provide the coverage you need in the event of a disaster.

What are the insurance company ratings?

Consumer analysis companies rate companies on a variety of factors. Since insurance is usually all about money, the most important criterion for evaluating insurers is financial stability. People depend on insurance companies to bail them out when disaster strikes. Any policy is purchased for the sole purpose of being financially covered in the event of any catastrophe that may befall your car, home or life, and if an insurer does not have a stable position in the industry, their ability to pay the claims becomes moot.

Although insurance company ratings primarily focus on financial strength, other factors are also taken into consideration. These include overall customer satisfaction, availability, coverage options, discounts and competitive pricing. Scores are also based on a company’s resilience to nationwide disasters. For example, a home insurance company will be rated for how well it handles business during severe weather events like hurricanes, while a health insurance company will be rated for the coverage it provides to policyholders during of a major case of disease spread across the country.

What do insurance scores take into account?

Insurance company ratings take into account a number of factors. Besides finances, the general health and ethics of the company are also considered before rating the insurer. Some other factors for consideration are:

  • Cash in reserve
  • Rate of endettement
  • Ethics and risk management
  • Income stream
  • Quality of policies taken out

Because every analytics company is different and follows different methods for determining scores, ratings may not always be consistent across all insurers. In addition to considering third-party reviews, it’s also important that you conduct your own independent research to find the best fit.

Who rates insurance companies

There are four companies whose scores for insurance providers stand out above all others. These are AM Best, Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s and Demotech.

AM Best

The most well-known insurance-specific rating company, the scores provided by AM Best are often considered the benchmark of financial strength in the industry. The highest grade offered is A++ (superior) while the lowest is a D (poor). AM Best does not assess any type of business other than insurance companies.

Standard & Poor’s

Unlike AM Best, Standard & Poor’s rates companies in all industries, including insurance. They assess companies’ ability and willingness to meet their financial obligations on time and in full. Or, in other words, they assess the likelihood that an insurance company can and will pay your claim in a timely manner. The highest score it offers is AAA (Extremely Strong) while the lowest is a D.


Another all-industry rating company, Moody’s Corporation, analyzes insurers for financial stability, market risk and overall performance. They do this for the purpose of determining, like other rating companies, the likelihood that an insurance company will be able to pay your claim on time. Their highest score is Aaa (highest quality) while C (lowest rated, usually default) is the lowest.


Ohio-based financial analyst Demotech rates insurance companies on their survivability regardless of market downturns. Its grading scale is a bit different, in that the highest grade offered is A” and the lowest an L, with A’, A, S, M in the middle.

Why are insurance company ratings important?

An insurance company is different from other businesses because it has a financial obligation to its customers. Insurance company ratings are important because they highlight an insurer’s financial stability and help people assess whether the company will be able to provide them with the money they need in the event of an accident or loss. disaster. However, since these ratings are objective and quite broad, they should not be the only factor determining the effectiveness of the company. Just because an insurance company is financially strong doesn’t mean it should be considered a guarantee of great customer service.

What if an insurance company has no rating?

Sometimes an insurance company may not be rated by one of the major rating agencies. It’s not always a negative indicator. In most cases, this simply means that the company is new and has not had many years in business, or that it only operates in a few regions and is not considered a national insurer. In the absence of financial ratings, it is better to focus on customer reviews to learn more about the performance of the company.

Other things to consider

Although the financial strength of an insurance company is important, it is far from the only factor to consider when looking for an insurer. In many cases, companies that are financially sound may not have the same reputation for customer service or paying claims in a timely manner. Therefore, reviewing customer complaints about an insurance company should be your first consideration.

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) maintains an index of complaints against insurance companies, with a median of 1. This index tells you the number of complaints registered against the company by consumers. The higher the score, the higher the number of complaints. You should also check customer reviews about the company’s handling of complaints, billing, renewal, and sudden price hikes. Coverage options and available discounts that help you save a few hundred dollars a year are also necessary factors to consider when looking for an insurance company.

You might also consider looking for a company’s JD Power score. JD Power specializes in collecting and analyzing data to provide an unbiased picture of a particular industry. This is important because if you look at customer reviews, many customers will take the time to write a bad review but won’t focus on the good things about the business. JD Power rates leading companies in the industry on criteria such as satisfaction with complaints handling and customer satisfaction. This company’s ratings can give you a good idea of ​​a company’s ability to serve you satisfactorily.

Frequently Asked Questions